Almost a week on from launching Cultist Simulator. How did it go? Here’s a mini-retrospective.

Surviving the Launch

CS has done well. More on that in a moment. I’m very happy it has. But this means we’ve been much, much busier in the last week than we expected, and we expected to be busy. After six months of beta testing, the game is in pretty solid shape, but I have a helpdesk queue full of edge-case save issues and black screen crashes on older versions of OSX. We’ve also got a mountain of feedback, press attention and old acquaintances getting in touch to say nice things.

And there are only two of us. We’re digging ourselves out from under, and we’re bringing in some freelance help, but we’re bloody glad we cleared our calendars for the week after launch. We will be slow to reply to everything for a few days yet. Lesson: clear your calendar in launch week.

A special mention for feedback. We’ve got a lot of feedback: lots of enthusiasm, lots of very specific requests, lots of people asking for an autosort feature or other UI tweaks, and the usual round of Internet nastiness. One guy suggested that my approach to game design should land me in the Hague for trial for crimes against humanity. I have developed a thick skin over ten years, and all things considered the feedback, even the negative stuff, is an overwhelmingly good thing to have. But ladies and gentlemen and others, hear me when I say, if you release an unexpectedly popular indie game on the Internet in 2018, this is what you have to be ready for:


What’s up next?

  • Bug fixing. The queue is beginning to look under control, but it’ll need a bit more work.
  • Modding support. I really want to enable simple modding support, and it’s about a day’s work that never quite made it in.
  • More content. I’m gagging to get back to work on this.
  • Localisation. A lot of players are asking about this. Lottie’s got this covered, and we’ll have more news in a while.
  • A mobile version. We had a porting partner nearly signed! and then they got offered a bigger and better project and (for reasons we sympathise with) couldn’t take the gig! We’ll get back to this. No timeline, though.
  • Brazil! We’ve been nominated for three awards at the Brazilian Independent Games Festival. So we’re flying out to Sao Paulo end of June. If you live there, say hi.

July will, we hope, be more normal. Though Lottie’s speaking at Develop.


Sales Figures

Everyone’s been asking about this, so I won’t tease you.

I’ve talked before about the importance of always trying to predict your numbers. Here’s what I thought back in March:

My casual top-down prediction would be that, if itch is 3% of Steam, this will amount to about 20K sales, which would put us firmly in the black for the year and make me very happy. 

I did give this some more thought. The total budget of Cultist Simulator, including freelancer costs and marketing, was 130K GBP (ish – we’re a bit behind on calculating the actuals). With our Kickstarter money and our advance funds from Humble Publishing, we needed to sell about 3K copies to break even. You need to do more than break even in gamedev, though.

I thought we would almost certainly sell 10K, which would be enough to call it a limited success and mean that with another Kickstarter and good DLC sales we could make another game. I was reasonably confident of 20K. 30K was my most optimistic case. “It’s not going to be another Sunless Sea,” I kept telling people, especially myself. “It’s half the budget, half the team size, half the time in development and we can’t use Fallen London to promote it like we did at Failbetter with Sea.”

On day 6, across all platforms, we’ve already sold more than 35,000 copies . This is almost exactly the number that Sea sold in the week after launch. I mean, eerily close. This makes me very happy but it also makes me genuinely existentially troubled about my complete inability, ten years and eight launches into my career, to predict commercial success. Next time I might just throw yarrow stalks.

But here you go: I am going to use Jake Birkett’s formula to assume that in year 1 we will sell 157K copies. (Sea sold 350K but just because lightning strikes twice, I’m not going to assume it’ll strike three times.)  I’ll see you in June 2019 and we’ll talk about that. I should note that our publisher, Humble, gets (deservedly) 30% of whatever we earn from this, and that a lot of those copies will be at a discounted price for store sales, so working out final predicted revenue isn’t straightforward, but yes, we made a profit, yes, we will definitely be supporting CS with updates, and yes, Weather Factory will be making more games.


How Did That Happen?

THIS IS NOT TRUE: ‘A game made by two people in a flat has a good chance of hitting #1 on Steam.’
THIS IS ALSO NOT TRUE: ‘As an indie, I should multiply my best-case sales estimates by about five’.

If you take either of those lessons away from this post, I have done you tremendous harm. Commercial indie game dev is not a lottery, not exactly, but it’s certainly a jungle in a storm. You might walk right past that path to safety, into the river, if you blink at the wrong moment.

But here are the things that I think helped us do this well, and that I tentatively recommend.

  • Luck. Unquestionably, and probably the biggest factor.
  • Community. We have a really nice, really active, really engaged community, and we talk to them constantly. This takes effort but it seems to have paid off.
  • Kickstarter. A successful Kickstarter campaign gives you an initial boost in buzz, the core of a community, pre-sales of your game, an opportunity to beta-test both your game and your marketing. I haven’t used other crowdfunding options, but I like KS a lot.
  • Humble’s support. We’ll never know how much difference this made, but we think a lot, obviously, or we wouldn’t have gone with them! Humble are a new name in publishing but they have reach and muscle. They put our name in front of their customers, they arranged a cross-promo with Slay the Spire, they helped connect us to press, they helped a lot with connecting us to streamers.
  • Lottie. My business partner, and better half, did a bloody good job of marketing the game. It’s not a job she loved, either, but it’s been her life for about two months. Even if you’re a small team, you probably need to make marketing someone’s job. (And if you ever have the opportunity to work with someone really smart who you trust completely… I recommend it.)
  • Streamers. Cultist Simulator streams surprisingly well, for a chilled, chatty sort of stream. This worked much better than we expected.
  • Existing reputation. I built Fallen London, I was creative director on Sunless Sea, I’ve worked at Bioware and Telltale and Paradox, and people know what an Alexis Kennedy project is like. It’s much tougher for first-timers.
  • Reviews. We got some really nice reviews on Day 1. It’s always hard to know how much press helps, but it can’t have bloody hurt.
  • Innovation. Everyone says ‘I’ve never seen anything like it.’ This is a total bastard when you’re trying to figure out who to show the game to (we kept asking people ‘If you like x, you’ll like Cultist Simulator. What is x?’ and never got many useful answers) but it does make us stand out.
  • CONTROVERSY!! A lot of people really, really like CS. Some people find it dull or incomprehensible. I think the game’s divisive nature has helped, actually. People who love it really love it, so they’re inclined to champion it.
  • A quick start. It’s a slow-paced game, but it runs in a window and starts up quickly. You get things happening in the first ten seconds of play. Sunless Sea, it’s like two minutes before anything really happens. I was very conscious that the first couple of minutes of a game are where you win or lose people.
  • I let my eight-year-old daughter press the button that released the game. I can’t absolutely guarantee this had anything to do with it, but if you have a small child about the place, it’s worth a shot.


There’s more, but…

I need a coffee, and then I have to get back to fixing bugs. More retrospective stuff from me and Lottie soon. I hope this was useful! if you’ve got qs, stick ’em in the comments.

  1. Good stuff. And it’s always nice to see a dev being totally upfront about figures! Working out what numbers one might (or in this case might not) expect can be super hard.

  2. I am so please that CS was welcomed by gamers with open arms confirming what us kickstarter backers already knew.
    Having watched the game evolve from the POC that was a simple webpage, into the early alpha and finally the finished game, as been glorious to watch.
    Bravo WeatherFactory

  3. It was your reputation that got me. I backed the Kickstarter as soon as I read “creator of FALLEN LONDON” without even reading the description. Your games have very strong themes and good world building and I for one will continue to purchase them.

  4. Wooooo, launch! Wooooo, Maxell guy!

    The whole idea of, you know, actually ‘being’ a cult, is such a great untapped market. I probably would have backed the Kickstarter just on hearing the title, but “Guy from Fallen London” sealed the deal and…was the alpha available back then? As soon as I played the alpha I knew it was something special.

  5. FWIW, CS is one of the very rare games that I’ve posted about on FB. At least one friend bought it because I told him about it, and he seemed to like it. I backed the KS, but had avoided the game until release so I went in cold and only had the sketchiest idea of how exactly all those cardy-wotzits were going to work. I really like that it is not like any other game I’ve ever played – so glad the release has gone so well!

  6. “If you like x, you’ll like Cultist Simulator. What is x?”
    X = Long Live The Queen

    Anyway, I really enjoy the game. Played it 17 hours over the weekend, started 3 cults and I think I have failed in all of the ways except the “Corner Office”.

  7. Well, I enjoy all the games by Zach Barth, and the press has occasionally called them ‘Zachlikes’, so we can call these…I dunno…Alexicides?


Post a Comment